Turner Constr. Co. v. Am. Mfrs. Mut. Ins. Co.
2007 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 32640 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 30, 2007)
Plaintiff Turner Construction Company entered into a construction management agreement with Central Synagogue in Manhattan for renovation work which included the installation of central air conditioning. The HVAC contractor on the project was Trident Mechanical Systems, Inc. During the project, a fire broke out, started by an employee of the roofing contractor who had been using a propane torch. The fire, which ordinarily would have caused minimal damage, was accelerated by exhaust fans that had been installed in the roof, and caused several millions of dollars damage to the landmark Synagogue. The Synagogue’s insurer, Wausau, sued Turner and some of the project’s contractors, to recover amounts it paid the Synagogue. The trial was bifurcated, trying liability first, then damages. Liability was determined as: Turner 50%, the roofing contractor 30%, the general contractor 15%, and Trident 0%. A settlement was reached before the damages portion of the trial began.
Continue Reading NY District Court Holds Trade Contractor’s Insurer Obligated to Indemnify CM Even Though Trade Contractor Found Not Negligent